Ideas for building a federated Roblox alternative
The requests (RedLib links):
https://farside.link/redlib/r/fediverse/comments/143j1j8/is_there_a_3d_metaverse_of_the_fediverse/
https://farside.link/redlib/r/opensourcegames/comments/rdub3p/comment/ho43ld1 (link to comment)
Fediverse games in general
The discussion:
The requests (RedLib links):
https://farside.link/redlib/r/fediverse/comments/iad25v/any_good_federated_gaming_platforms/
https://farside.link/redlib/r/gamedev/comments/12e7fum/game_on_fediverse/
The rejected Minetest suggestion:
https://github.com/minetest/minetest/issues/7993
A blog
I’m not sure if ActivityPub allows for an extension like that. And I mean if you open up a separate direct channel via TURN… It’ll be incompatible with something like Mastodon anyways, so I then don’t see a good reason for why to bother with the additional overhead of AP in the first place. I mean you could then just send the status updates in some efficient binary representation as data packets directly do the other players. So why use ActivityPub that needs to encode that in some JSON, send it to your home instance, which handles it, puts it in the outbox, sends HTTP POST requests to the inboxes of your teammates where it then needs to be retrieved by them… In my eyes it’s just a very complicated and inefficient way of transferring the data and I really don’t see any benefits at all.
So instead of extending AP and wrapping the game state updates into AP messages, I’d just send them out directly and skip AP altogether. That probably reduces the program code needed to be written from like 20 pages to 2 and makes the data arrive nearly instantly.
I suppose I could imagine ActivityPub being part of other things in a game, though. Just not the core mechanics… For example it could do the account system. Or achievements or some collectibles which can then be commented and liked by other players.
The TURN channel could be used ONLY for live multiplayer interactions (and everything else that needs dynamic state updates), while everything else (e.g. game data, achievements, avatar data, other static things) would be in AP
deleted by creator