SPOILERS for Star Trek Enterprise potentially

I was noticing it was tough for me to get into shows that started after the 2000s, and talking to someone I mused about how it must be because of 9/11. I was watching Enterprise at the time, on the season just before 2001, and sure enough, the episodes after 9/11 had a complete shift in tone, the show becoming basically 24, sci-fi War on Terror immediately. It’s like a parody of ‘if Starfleet had to make the hard choices to make America safe from space Al Qaeda’ or something. Overall the show is better than I was expecting though, still got me hooked on the trekness.

It was clear there was a cultural shift after 9/11, especially in the mainstream US media. It was interesting to be able to see it so distinctly in a show that went from the pre- to post- era. Does anyone else have any good examples of that happening in shows that spanned that shift?

  • darkcalling [comrade/them, she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    5 days ago

    It was definitely a shift. But a stark one. I’d like to point out that there was another shift but a more subtle one that occurred with the collapse (via illegal dissolution) of the USSR and the end of the cold war with capitalist victory and end of history.

    Nerding out

    You can see it in DS9 and Voyager, though some of that is down to the death of Roddenberry himself as well no doubt. The shows closest to showing a communist future suddenly decided to get dark (whereas other more capitalist aligned shows were all sunshine thinking that the world was good and safe now), to insert fiat currency, gambling, etc prominently. It became unthinkable and too far-fetched to consider a better world, suddenly Star Fleet is being drawn to reflect American propaganda about the USSR, secret groups within it acting outright maliciously, crushing dissent, oppressing people, doing murderous conspiracies as part of an official secret “section” (secret police you might say) rather than say a group of bad people operating without official sanction and going rogue as happened in a TNG movie. Contrast to ToS where the problem was essentially ignorant or pompous commissar stand-ins throwing their weight around without understanding things “in the field” as Kirk did. You even have anti-state groups in the maquis who show up in DS9 to push the agenda that this communist galactic government is in fact so bad that there are those willing to rise up against it and be seen as heroes, something continued to a degree in Voy.

    I’d say collectively the two shifts dealt a death blow to ST as a franchise. I lost interest in ENT very early on by the second season. There’s really no coming back from that kind of liberal restoration.